Here’s why waiting three days to call after a great date is terrible advice. Playing “cool” is out, … [+]
We’ve all heard the infamous three-day rule: after a great first date, you’re supposed to wait three days before calling or texting to avoid seeming “too eager.” This outdated advice has stuck around for decades, perpetuating the idea that interest must be hidden to keep the “mystery” alive.
But playing nice is not only unnecessary, but also counterproductive. Hinge DATE’s latest report found that 56% of Gen Z Hinge lovers have held back from communicating their interest and lost a potential relationship because they were worried about rejection.
“The idea that you can put yourself out there and be rejected by someone you value so much is terrifying. There have been times in my life, I’m sure the feelings were mutual, but the ‘what if’ kept us both from moving forward. Over time, I learned that people are like spiders: they are as afraid of you as you are of them,” he says. Hinge Date Khai Bellamy.
So if you’re really interested in someone after a first date, the last thing you should do is hold back. Instead, start practicing what I call “post-meeting hygiene,” which refers to the immediate actions and communication that follow a first meeting with someone you want to continue seeing.
By practicing good post-date hygiene, you take advantage of a critical window to deepen your connection and show emotional availability, two key ingredients for a healthy and lasting relationship.
Here are two ways to maintain your hygiene after the date.
1. Don’t wait too long to register after the date
One of the biggest mistakes people make after a great first date is waiting too long to reach out. This hesitation ends up sending the wrong message: disinterest. Conversely, checking in earlier rather than later shows that you are confident in your feelings and emotionally available, which is much more appealing than playing games.
A simple message like, “hey, I had a great time today! I really enjoyed our conversations and the energy you brought to the meeting,” can go a long way. Mentioning something memorable or funny from the date—whether it’s an inside joke or a particularly interesting topic you discussed—adds a personal touch and shows that you were truly engaged.
For example, Tinder’s This year’s Green Flags study found that 59% of heterosexual women considered it chivalrous and careful when their date made sure they got home safely after the date.
Such gestures create an instant connection, reinforcing positive feelings from the date and leaving your match with a sense of security and clarity about where they stand with you. It also opens the door for follow-up conversations.
2. Be consistent
Consistency is the foundation of good post-date hygiene. After a promising first date, it’s important to let your date know that your interest isn’t fleeting. Trying to stay consistent in your communication signals emotional responsiveness and honesty, two traits that are highly valued in relationships.
So what does sustainability look like in practice? First, it means keeping in touch regularly. You don’t need to bombard your date with texts or phone calls, but maintaining a consistent level of communication helps keep the relationship alive.
Hinge The DATE report also mentions the importance of practicing good “digital body language” or DBL, which includes timely, authentic and thoughtful responses rather than delayed or one-word responses. 77% of users found this to be an important indicator of a match’s interest. Such communication also gives you an opportunity to learn more about their worldview and your compatibility.
Making concrete plans for a second date is another important element of consistency. Instead of vague statements like “let’s hang out sometime,” make an effort to plan something specific, meaningful, or fun that takes both of your interests into account. For example, if your date mentions that they like to try new food, suggest a new restaurant to try together. Or, if they say they like to be outside, plan a casual walk or walk in the park.
In addition to logistical endurance, emotional endurance is just as critical. This means being emotionally available and open about your feelings as the relationship progresses. If you are interested, say so. If you’re curious about something they mentioned during the meeting, follow up and ask.
Post-date hygiene isn’t just about being polite or following social norms—it’s about creating a strong emotional foundation early in the relationship. Many people only focus on how well the date went, but overlook the importance of what happens next.
Good post-date hygiene isn’t just about date number two either—it’s about setting the stage for a relationship where both people feel valued, appreciated, and excited to spend more time together. An investment is made in the possible future you may have with this person.
So the next time you go on a great first date, ditch the three-day rule and make a move that reflects your authentic feelings. It could be the start of something really special, but only if you let it.
Does your fear of intimacy keep you from going on dates? Take this quiz to learn more: The degree of fear of intimacy